I have always had this confusion. Should I be saying “No bile duct dilatation.” or “No bile duct dilation.”? Is there a difference?
I thought it was only me but I soon realized that I am not alone. In fact, there are actual PubMed indexed journal papers on this topic! I could at least find four :).
And even the #radtwitter had its own reservations:
And the debate is not limited to radiologists as even obstetricians, cardiologists and ophthalmologists frequently encounter this term.
So is there any difference between dilatation and dilation ? What is the correct usage?
Lets dig into the history a bit. According to Google Ngram (a search engine that charts word frequencies from a large corpus of books that were printed between 1500 and 2019), word dilatation has been used more frequently in literature than dilation as depicted in this graphic but recently the latter has taken over. Although using Google Ngram is not an ideal method to track usage (a post on the WIRED describes it as seductively simple), it does gives us a basic idea.
Even in the scientific literature, the word dilatation has been more common than dilation as per an article published by Mahroof et al. in the British Journal of Opthalmology.
Bloom et.al concluded that these words convey the same meaning and conclude by saying: “Attempted distinction between the two, namely that of an action versus a condition, seems arbitrary and without historical evidence or support. ” A few authors have suggested that the ORIGINAL word dilatation has been shortened by Americans to dilation to save space, which according to me is hard to believe.
So can you and should you use these terms interchangeably? The answer is no. At least that what I think. Here is my understanding :
There is pancreatic duct dilatation (noun) secondary to an ampullary adenocarcinoma.
vs.
Outcomes of ampulla dilation with different sized balloons to remove common bile duct (CBD) stones were studied.
And
Ampullary dilation techniques can be used to achieve dilatation of the CBD.
Also:
- Ophthalmologist dilate the pupils.
- Obstetricians dilate the cervix.
Another differentiation is that dilation usually refers to physiological processes such as dilation of pupils, vessels and cervix vis-a-vis dilatation which refers to surgical procedures such as dilatation and curettage, balloon dilation valvuloplasty.
Here is a list of all articles using these terms on PubMed: (dilation) OR (dilatation) on Pubmed. How many of these do you think have used the term incorrectly? I could spot at least a few in the top 100 results.
Hopefully I have made it easier for you. Or have I confused you more? Let me know your thoughts in the comments!
PS: Follow me on Twitter @radiogyan
Check out previous articles here:
Good stuff!
I always used to have this confusion. Thanks for sharing :).
Cody.
“Another differentiation is that dilation usually refers to physiological processes such as dilation of pupils, vessels and cervix vis-a-vis dilatation which refers to surgical procedures such as dilatation and curettage, balloon dilation valvuloplasty.”
I think you used the wrong word! Is it cervical dilatation or dilation there?
Hey Ilya,
My understanding is that if it physiological, it would be cervical dilation. If it is done surgically, it would be dilatation.